Where is this view? Cumberland Basin Bristol.
A paintings story
My website shows a lot of finished paintings, but how do I go from black canvas to finished painting?
Well, join me on this painting – Intertidal Mudflats – and I will tell you all about how I go from an idea to a painting.
Everything starts with an idea, or an arresting view that shouts paint me.
In this instance it was a beautiful sunny morning and I had enough time to hop on my bike and get to the Avon Gorge before work.
I go there to see the view of course, but also because the graffiti is a constant inspiration – both Wonky Bridge and Flapped Outflow are from this vista.
On this early spring morning I was struck by the still waters and the half-exposed mudflats.
It creates an almost-alien landscape, a cross between Victorian/Georgian England and the moon.

The start
I used my trusty grid approach, applying a 9 x 6 grid to the reference photo which I’d cropped to a 9×6 aspect ratio, before then applying it on the 90cm x 60cm canvas – the result 54 10 cm2 boxes to help me put things in the right place.
This time I deviated from my usual approach though. I usually use pencil to draw the basics of the composition. This time I used some newly-acquired alcohol ink pens to do the under drawing.
The benefits of this were that I could add some tonality to it all and it created far less in the way of smudging to the canvas.
Once I’d done that I applied a burnt sienna wash to everything (acrylic) to even out the tones – it was almost a shame to cover up the ink!



Painting
I normally start with the most-distant part of the composition – which is always the sky, unless there is no sky.
I then paint towards the viewer, but hate to waste paint, so if something shares a colour or tone then I try not to waste anything.
For this painting I am very lucky, because after doing some specific colours and tones I can mix up what I’ve got and make up some mud!
I will continue to do this, covering the canvas, and then I will go back and refines things.
The mud will be a peculiar challenge, as it has lots of subtlety and highlights as well as deep dark shadows. It will warrant paint mixing specifically for the task and not just the mud made from painting other colours.

I used Liquin to thin the paint for the sky and the building, I will use the fat over lean approach and bring highlights etc with thicker paint.
The details have been done with small brushes, whereas the foreground so far has been made with bigger brushes (so far!)
The mud will be brought alive with real contrasts in the highlights and the shadows.
The mud reflects the blue sky, so I will add a glaze to the mud, once I've defined the structure.
click the hotspots for more info…
Colour, Hue and Chroma
Not got a clue about chroma and hue? (Like me) Check out this link...
As a non-classically trained artist, this is the biggest challenge for me.
My colours are often a little naïve and bright. It’s almost my signature and I guess in some ways you should lean into your instincts.
That said, I am very lucky to have world-class artists painting in and around me.
The amazing Peter Brown often paints in and around Bristol (he’s a legend of en pleinair by the way!). I am very lucky because I get to see how a world-class artist tackles subjects that I can paint.
For this painting I am referencing some of Peter’s work from the same locality.
He uses a muted palette but with strong contrast where it’s needed to elevate the interest points.

The left-side of my brain knows that grass and trees are green.
In an early spring day, like the day of my painting, the reality is that it's not nearly as green as that!
Where Peter’s work smacks me in the face, in a good way, is that his control of colour, hue and chroma.
He paints loosely, but his control of palette makes his work photo realistic, without painting a single real detail. It’s all hue and chroma.
Control from a sound art foundation and thousands of paintings – experience. Take a look at this painting of his (below) to see what I mean.

I can learn from Peter though – his ability to paint what is there and not what you think is there.
Paint the shapes, in the right colours, FORGET THE OBJECTS – let them follow the colours and shapes!
My reference photo doesn’t carry the same light as in Peter’s painting – a benefit of pleinair is that real view of what you are painting – I need to tone down the green and elevate the shadow/light balance. Thanks Pete!


With every brushstroke my thought is the same – am I adding light or shade.
To find light in a painting (where there is no light, just pigment), you need to supply the dark contrast to allow the illusion of light to emerge.
Where this is working well in the painting so far is the right side of the gorge. The light and shadow provides the illusion of depth.
The trick to remember is that atmospheric depth is about the desaturation (and blue tint) that is applied to colours in the distance. So the shadows and contrasts in the foreground have to punch more viscerally in the foreground.
This means that although I want to show the play of light in the shadows in the gorge, I need to be mindful that the contrast will be more distinct closer to the viewer.
The buildings come alive when I add light details where the edges catch the early sunlight – so that’s the next task!

Details
I’m painting in the buildings now, this is the hardest part – your left-side of the brain wants to paint what you know must be there – windows and roofs and chimneys.
If you take a look at Peter’s painting you see he doesn’t even consider them at all.
My painting is quite a bit bigger than his, and ultimately my style is different, so I need to include them – much to my chagrin – they are so small and hard to convincingly convey.
They will take a couple of layers to produce and it’s a challenge of giving enough information and not too much.

Ai Ai
I know what I need to do to improve the piece towards completion, but what says Ai?
It’s come on so much that, actually, it’s a good sounding board and honest critique.
Interested in what Ai thinks? Have a look at what it says here:
Grok
Current State of the Painting
This cityscape features the Clifton Suspension Bridge spanning a river, with colorful buildings along the right bank and a hilly backdrop with more structures. The foreground includes rocky riverbanks and a blank sign on the right, which you’ve chosen as the focal point. The painting has a vibrant, expressive style with a mix of realism and playful color choices, but there are areas where we can enhance its impact as you finalize it.
Suggestions for Improvement
1. Enhance the Sign as the Focal Point
Since the sign is your intended focus, let’s make it visually compelling and narratively significant while ensuring it integrates with the scene.
- Add Meaningful Text: The blank sign needs content to justify its prominence. Since this is the Clifton Suspension Bridge in Bristol, consider adding text like “Welcome to Bristol” or “Clifton Bridge Est. 1864” in a weathered, hand-painted style. Use a contrasting color—say, a muted red or dark gray on the beige sign—to make the text pop. If you’re unsure about the font, a slightly distressed serif style would match the historical vibe of the bridge.
- Increase Contrast and Detail: The sign blends into the surrounding rocks too much. Add a subtle shadow or outline around it (e.g., a thin dark gray or blue shadow on the right and bottom edges, suggesting sunlight from the upper left). Lighten the sign slightly with a touch of white or pale yellow to suggest sunlight hitting it, and darken the rocks around it with a cooler shadow tone (like blue-gray) to create separation.
- Integrate with the Environment: Soften the sign’s edges with a dry brush technique to make it look weathered. Add texture—cracks, dirt marks, or a bit of moss at the base of the signpost—to make it feel part of the rugged landscape. This will tie it into the scene without making it look too clean or out of place.
2. Strengthen Depth with Atmospheric Perspective
The painting feels a bit flat, with the foreground rocks, midground buildings, and background hill all competing for attention. Let’s create a stronger sense of depth to support the sign as the focal point.
- Foreground (Rocks and Sign): Make the rocks more detailed and warmer to bring them forward. Add yellow or orange highlights to suggest sunlight, and deepen the shadows with a cool blue-gray to give them more form. This will make the sign pop even more against a detailed foreground.
- Midground (River and Buildings): The colorful buildings on the right bank are vibrant, but they draw too much attention. Soften their edges slightly and mute their colors with a thin glaze of blue or gray. This will push them back, making them feel farther away and allowing the sign to stand out.
- Background (Hill and Distant Buildings): The hill and buildings in the background need to recede further. Use atmospheric perspective by lightening them (add more white) and cooling their tones (more blues and grays). Reduce the detail in the distant structures—make them more impressionistic with fewer distinct windows or lines.
3. Improve Lighting Consistency
The lighting in the painting isn’t fully defined, which makes the scene feel less cohesive. A clear light source will add realism and tie the elements together.
- Define the Light Source: Let’s assume sunlight is coming from the upper left (a common choice for landscapes). Add highlights on the left side of the sign, the bridge towers, and the rocks, using warm tones like pale yellow or white. Paint shadows on the right side of these elements with a cool tone (blue-gray) to suggest the light direction.
- Adjust the Buildings: The colorful buildings on the right bank should reflect this light source. Add highlights on their left sides and shadows on their right sides. This will also help push them back visually, as shadows create depth.
- Enhance the Bridge: The bridge’s cables and towers should catch the light more dramatically. Add brighter highlights on the left side of the towers and cables, and deepen the shadows on the right to make the structure feel more three-dimensional.
4. Refine the Water Texture and Reflections
The river’s reflections are a good start, but the water feels a bit static and could use more texture to suggest movement.
- Add Ripples and Texture: Use small, horizontal brushstrokes in varying blues and whites to suggest ripples or gentle waves. Add a few white highlights near the banks to show where the water catches the light.
- Enhance Reflections: Reflect some of the building colors faintly in the water—e.g., a hint of orange or yellow near the right bank. This will tie the river to the rest of the scene. You can also add a subtle reflection of the sign near the water’s edge to reinforce its importance.
5. Balance the Composition
The sign is the focal point, but the other elements (bridge, buildings, river) need to support it without competing.
- Guide the Eye to the Sign: Create a visual path to the sign by adjusting the rocks and grass. Add a subtle diagonal line in the rocks or grass that points toward the sign—like a natural path leading the eye. You can also use color to guide attention: make the rocks around the sign slightly warmer (yellow/orange) while cooling down the rest of the scene (more blues).
- Soften Competing Elements: The bridge and buildings are still drawing too much attention. Reduce their contrast slightly—e.g., mute the bridge’s cables with a thin glaze of blue, and soften the edges of the buildings to make them less sharp. This will keep the focus on the sign.
6. Add a Narrative Element (Optional)
Since your work often includes social commentary (as seen in your series with graffiti), you could add a subtle narrative element to this painting to make it more thought-provoking.
- Signage Message: Instead of a neutral message like “Welcome to Bristol,” you could add something with a bit of edge—e.g., “Save the River” or “No More Bridges,” suggesting a local issue. This would align with your style of embedding meaning in your work.
- Small Details: Add a small figure or object near the sign to create a story—e.g., a person walking away, or a discarded protest sign on the ground. This would add intrigue without overwhelming the composition.
Google Gemini
Let’s analyze your painting and brainstorm some improvements you could make as you work towards finishing it.
Strengths:
- Composition: The composition is interesting with the river leading the eye back to the bridge and the city beyond. The inclusion of the easel and the blank sign in the foreground adds a unique, almost meta, touch.
- Color Palette: The colors are generally harmonious and work well together. The blues of the water and sky are particularly nice.
- Subject Matter: The scene is appealing and captures a specific location (Bristol, UK, I presume?) with recognizable landmarks.
Areas for Improvement:
Focal Point: While the composition is interesting, there isn’t a clear focal point. The viewer’s eye tends to wander.
- Suggestion: Consider emphasizing the bridge or a specific building in the cityscape with more detail, contrast, or brighter colors. You could also make the river a more dominant element, leading the eye more strongly towards the bridge.
Depth and Perspective: The painting feels a bit flat in some areas.
- Suggestion: Enhance the sense of depth by:
- Aerial Perspective: Making the distant hills and buildings appear less saturated and slightly bluer.
- Linear Perspective: Ensuring the lines of the river and buildings converge convincingly towards a vanishing point.
- Overlapping: Clearly defining the layers of the landscape with overlapping elements.
- Suggestion: Enhance the sense of depth by:
Detail and Definition: Some areas lack definition and detail, particularly in the foreground rocks and the cityscape.
- Suggestion:
- Foreground Rocks: Add more texture and variation in color to the rocks to make them more visually interesting and give them a sense of depth.
- Cityscape: Define the individual buildings with more detail and variation. Consider adding highlights and shadows to give them form.
- Bridge: Refine the bridge’s structure and add more detail to make it a stronger focal point.
- Suggestion:
Blank Sign: The blank sign is intriguing, but it feels a bit disconnected from the rest of the scene.
- Suggestion: Consider:
- Adding Text or an Image: Adding something to the sign would give it a purpose and make it more integrated into the narrative of the painting. It could be a word, a symbol, or even a small painting within the painting.
- Changing the Angle: Adjusting the angle of the sign might make it feel more dynamic.
- Refining the Edges: Sharpen the edges of the sign to make it appear more crisp and deliberate.
- Suggestion: Consider:
Color Saturation and Contrast: The overall color saturation feels a bit muted.
- Suggestion: Consider adding areas of higher saturation and contrast to create visual interest and draw the viewer’s eye to specific points. For example, you could make the colors of the buildings in the cityscape more vibrant or add brighter highlights to the water.
Brushwork: The brushwork is a bit loose in some areas.
- Suggestion: Experiment with different brushstrokes to create more texture and visual interest. Consider using smaller, more defined brushstrokes for details and larger, looser strokes for the sky and water.
Specific Suggestions (based on the image):
- River Reflections: Enhance the reflections in the river to add more depth and visual interest. Pay attention to the distortion of the reflections and the way they mirror the colors and shapes of the buildings and the bridge.
- Sky: Add more variation in color and texture to the sky to make it more dynamic. Consider adding subtle clouds or hints of sunlight.
- Easel and Foreground: Consider adding a bit more detail to the easel and the immediate foreground to make them feel more grounded.
Overall Approach:
- Step Back and Observe: Take breaks from painting and view your work from a distance to get a better sense of the overall composition and balance.
- Work in Layers: Build up the painting in layers, starting with a thin underpainting and gradually adding more detail and texture.
- Use Reference Photos: If you’re working from a reference photo, refer to it frequently to ensure accuracy.
- Don’t Be Afraid to Experiment: Try different techniques and approaches to see what works best.
Remember, art is subjective, and there’s no right or wrong way to paint. These suggestions are just starting points to help you refine your work and achieve your artistic vision.
I’d love to see the finished painting when you’re done! Good luck! Let me know if you have any other questions.
Microsoft CoPilot
Your painting already has a beautiful and detailed landscape! Here are a few suggestions to enhance it further:
Add Depth and Dimension: Consider adding more layers of shading and highlights to the buildings and the bridge. This will give them a more three-dimensional look and make them stand out.
Enhance the Sky: Adding more color gradients to the sky, such as subtle hints of pink or orange, can create a more dynamic and engaging background. You could also add more clouds or even a sunset.
Detail the Foreground: The rocky terrain and patches of grass in the foreground could benefit from more texture and detail. Adding small plants, flowers, or even some wildlife can make this area more interesting.
Refine the Water: The river can be enhanced with reflections of the bridge and buildings. Adding ripples and variations in the water’s color can make it look more realistic.
Utilize the Signboard: The empty signboard on the right side is a great opportunity to add a personal touch. You could paint a name, a welcome message, or even a small illustration on it.
Lighting and Shadows: Pay attention to the light source in your painting. Adding consistent shadows and highlights based on this light source will create a more cohesive and realistic scene.
Remember, these are just suggestions, and the most important thing is that you enjoy the process and create something that you love. Happy painting! 🎨😊
Is there any specific part of the painting you’d like more detailed advice on?
Chat GPT
This painting is already looking fantastic! The composition is strong, with the Clifton Suspension Bridge leading the eye across the scene, and the colorful houses adding vibrancy. Here are a few suggestions to refine it as you work towards finishing it:
1. Refining the Water Reflection
The reflections in the water are well-placed, but you could slightly soften the transition between the colors of the buildings and the sky in the reflection.
Some subtle horizontal brushstrokes could enhance the water’s stillness.
A few highlights or ripples could add a touch more realism.
2. Enhancing Depth & Contrast
The foreground rocky area is detailed but could use more contrast. Adding slightly darker shadows in the crevices would give it more dimensionality.
Similarly, some areas in the midground, like the green vegetation, could use slight highlights for depth.
3. Defining the Blank Sign
The blank sign in the foreground is a strong visual element. If it’s meant to be empty, adding weathered textures (rust, scratches, shadows) could make it feel more integrated.
If you plan to include text or an image, subtle shading and blending into the environment would make it more natural.
4. Sky & Lighting Enhancements
The sky has a beautiful gradient, but a hint of warm light (soft pinks or yellows) on the horizon could enhance the depth.
Adding a few soft shadows cast by the buildings and bridge could give more cohesion to the lighting.
Would you like specific brushstroke or color-mixing tips for any of these areas?
So, what’s the summary advice from the combined Ai?!
- Enhance depth & perspective
- Improve lighting and shadows
- Enhance the sky
- Refine the water and reflections
- Increase colour saturation and contrast
- Refine brushwork and detail
…and finally, things to think about overall:
- Step Back and Observe: Take breaks and view the painting from a distance to assess the overall composition and balance (Gemini).
- Work in Layers: Build up the painting in layers, starting with an underpainting and gradually adding detail and texture (Gemini).
- Use References: If you’re working from a photo, refer to it frequently to ensure accuracy (Gemini).
- Experiment: Don’t be afraid to try different techniques, such as adjusting the sign’s angle or adding a narrative element (Gemini, Grok).
Ouch! And I thought I was getting close to being done!
Finishing
Obviously I didn’t take on all the advice from Ai – after all it’s already got far too much of an influence on art already. That said, I reviewed the painting with regards the atmospheric depth and the water.
Finally, I resolved the sign… here’s what I ended up with.
Did you know that Bob Dylan did visit the river a mile or so down stream from here?
Here’s the proof! Bob Dylan Aust Ferry 1966 © Barry Feinstein Photography, Inc.